How do you make an out of character moment believable?

[Bob Bobson]

I have a character that I have established always does the right thing. I’ve reached the point in the plot where he acts very selfishly but it seems unrealistic. How can I make that part believable?

[Matthew Brown]

I am so glad that someone asked this question, Bob (cool name by the way). This question is really about one of my favourite topics, the cycle of choice.

What you are trying to do is steer the reader through a process of a character making a choice that is unexpected. This process has four steps.

1. Emotion
2. Logic
3. Anticipation
4. Action

Out of character actions are driven by two factors – emotions and anticipation of the outcome.

We start the scene with the emotional reaction to the events that have gone before. For example, if the best friend was just shot dead emotions might be shock and grief. These emotions may, or may not, cloud what comes next. They will certainly colour it.

Then, after the emotional dust has settled – perhaps as soon as a paragraph later – we get to logic. In our example, the character has just seen their friend shot. They ducked in reaction but now they have to think about what to do next. Our character is a brave hero and we expect them to fight back. They think logically about the next steps. Gun ready, they think logically about where the shooter is.

Then comes anticipation. This is coloured by the grief and shock at the loss of a friend. They anticipate death, they realise that the news they are carrying will be lost. They imagine that the mission will fail.

Instead of attacking, which we would expect, they look around and, seeing an exit, they leg it.

What we did was talk the reader through the steps of thought that went from brave soldier to running away.

You can apply this process to any character and if the emotional, logical, and anticipation parts line up to justify an apparently out of character moment, the action seems logical.

Of course, our brave hero will have to deal with the shame of running away and that may colour and drive the rest of the story.

I hope that helps.

[Matthew Brown]

I’ve recently written a post for Thanet Creative which dives into the issue of extreme right turns for characters and the whole scene and scene sequel cycle. If you need more help, this might be of use.

The scene and scene-sequel

• This reply was modified 5 years, 8 months ago by Matthew Brown.

[Christian Writer]

Your embed is not working.

[Jason Latnar]

Works for me.

Edit: Doh, just saw the date. sorry.

• This reply was modified 5 years, 4 months ago by Jason Latnar.

[Matthew Brown]

Ah yes. That was caused by our move to https for better security.
Fixed it.

[jeffjohns]

Let me see if I got this right. You step the reader through the characters thought process so that the OOCM seems rational.

Is that right?

[Matthew Brown]

Let me see if I got this right. You step the reader through the characters thought process so that the OOCM seems rational.

Is that right?

Basically, yes.

[jeffjohns]

What about foreshadowing?

[Matthew Brown]

What about foreshadowing?

I would focus on the character’s fears. The anticipation phase is where you will find the character making extreme choices.

If, for example, he is afraid of losing standing in the community, that fear will be part of his anticipation.

If you establish the fear early on then it will be all the more compelling when they make that unexpected u-turn on morality road.

Likewise, anything else you can foreshadow so that their anticipation is realistic will anchor the moment as dark but real. For example, a girl who fears her father will reject her if he discovers that she is pregnant might be shown seeing her father kick out her older sister for the same reason. Now, this pro-life girl is set up to make a pro-choice decision.

[jeffjohns]

This should be pinned. So helpful.

[Author]

Posts